DJI Mavic, Air and Mini Drones
Friendly, Helpful & Knowledgeable Community
Join Us Now

Mavic3 vs SonyA9

Erk1024

Well-Known Member
Premium Pilot
Joined
Oct 9, 2024
Messages
148
Reactions
256
Age
57
Location
Pompano Beach, FL
1729276858223.png

When I got my Mavic3 Pro, I took some test shots and noticed some softness in the corners at 100%. Viewing images at 100% is not a hypothetical for me because I have an 8K x 2K ultrawide monitor and when I make wallpapers for it, you see every pixel. In any case, I wanted to see how it compared to my regular (terrestrial) cameras.

In order to test it, I used the full frame Sony A9 which has a similar resolution (24 megapixels), and the Sony 24-105mm zoom lens. This lens isn't perfect by any stretch, but it's good enough that I'm fine with the images I get out of it. If the Mavic3 can keep up with that lens, then it should be good enough for the photos I wanted to take.

So I put up some test charts and started shooting. My camera's zoom starts at f/4, so that's the lowest aperture for an apples to apples test. So let's start there.

Here is an image of the center of both lenses:

1729277269984.png

They both look really solid--no complaints. Keep in mind, this is 100% zoom and just a small region of the overall image. One thing that's odd is that the Mavic3 had some unexpected color patterns that it somehow got out of a black and white image. I'm assuming this is some weirdness with the demosaic process, but I'm not too worried about it.

Next I looked at the corners. Here is the top left corner:

1729277625426.png

There is definitely some softness here. But what's amazing is that I think the Mavic3 lens is just a bit sharper? Wow. That's impressive. I realize that I'm comparing a "prime" lens to a "zoom" lens, but the Mavic3's lens is also *tiny*. One thing to notice is that there is significantly more noise from the Micro 4/3's sensor, even at ISO-100. Also the corner is quite a bit darker than the center, so there is some significant vignetting. The Mavic2 Pro had quite a bit of vignetting (caused by having a small lens).

The other thing I notice is that you probably don't want to go past f/7.1 on the Mavic3, as you start to get a lot of softening of the image because of diffraction. For example, f/11 is very soft, even in the center of the image.

If you want to look at the full size images yourself, I've put them on a Google Drive.

My overall conclusion is that the Mavic3's main lens/camera combo is plenty good enough to take excellent image quality photos. What limitations there are can be worked around for great results. :)
 
Last edited:
All the posts I've seen on the M3 is that f5.6 is the sweet spot.
I would argue that the sweet spot is between f4.5 and f5. Upon very close examination I am starting to see very slight softening of the image at f5.6 as the diffraction is starting to have effect. But the sharpness uniformity across the entire frame is still best at f5.6 despite the minor (barely visible) degradation of overall sharpness.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Erk1024
My overall conclusion is that the Mavic3's main lens/camera combo is plenty good enough to take excellent image quality photos. What limitations there are can be worked around for great results.
Thank you Erik for the work you've put in here on the forum !
 
  • Like
Reactions: Erk1024

DJI Drone Deals

New Threads

Forum statistics

Threads
134,641
Messages
1,597,146
Members
163,133
Latest member
stevemaller
Want to Remove this Ad? Simply login or create a free account