DJI Mavic, Air and Mini Drones
Friendly, Helpful & Knowledgeable Community
Join Us Now

Manual or Auto for video settings?

Topo

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 5, 2018
Messages
131
Reactions
75
I have always chosen auto, not wanting to add to the complexity of set up, as well as not knowing enough about what to actually set manually. But I thought its worth asking what everyone else uses. Do you find better results configuring manually for exposure? I understand there are not as many manual settings options as the Pro or 2Pro. What is the consensus? Maybe this is a can of worms discussion, but, where better to ask. thanks
 
You need to use manual unless you are OK with uneven footage (which can be fine for some scenarios or if you're just messing around).

Generally what can happen if if you leave it in auto:

- If your shutter speed gets too slow or too fast you can have very blurry footage (too slow) or footage that stutters (too fast), and when it changes shutter speed you will see slight exposure differences
- The drone might raise ISO off of base (100) which is almost never ideal, especially on the tiny sensor in the Mavic Air. Again when it changes this mid-footage, you will see it.
- If you use auto WB you might have unwanted color shifts in your footage as you move from, say, cloudy to sunny conditions

You can see the theme is uneven footage - presumably you want to avoid that.

The Air has a fixed aperture (2.8) so there is less to worry about there, but a greater need for ND filters.

Most people shoot in full manual, and that is best practice if you want to get the best footage possible out of the Air. That is obviously not a rule, but generally speaking full manual is what you will want to do if you are trying to get the most out of your footage.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mike Shock and Topo
Thanks CD. That's a good start. What is considered "full manual"? What, exactly, is necessary before taking off? White balance is pretty clear - sunny, cloudy, etc. Are mid-flight changes to exposure common? I see the Pro has a dedicated wheel for exposure, and now see that the latest Air firmware has allowed that multi-use function to the gimbal wheel. But I don't know what that adjustment changes, or whether it's an advantage to use it. I have 3 ND's; 4, 8, and 16.
 
What I usually do is hover, point the gimbal down some so I don't have any sky, let it auto set exposure, then lock it. Once I lock it, I can tilt back up to get some sky.
Otherwise the ground is too dark, being biased by the bright sky.
 
Thanks CD. That's a good start. What is considered "full manual"? What, exactly, is necessary before taking off? White balance is pretty clear - sunny, cloudy, etc. Are mid-flight changes to exposure common? I see the Pro has a dedicated wheel for exposure, and now see that the latest Air firmware has allowed that multi-use function to the gimbal wheel. But I don't know what that adjustment changes, or whether it's an advantage to use it. I have 3 ND's; 4, 8, and 16.

Full manual would just be manual mode in the drone's exposure settings, and selecting a manual white balance in the WB settings. It's simpler than it may sound, but can be intimidating at first.

With experience you will be able to look at the conditions and pretty much know what ND filter is required, but you can pick up the drone and point it at the scene to get a rough idea. Once you're in the air, you can tweak the shutter speed if necessary as you will have a little bit of leeway. Try not to raise ISO above 100, but if you need to in order to get the shot, obviously that is better than no shot. The ND set you have will be perfect for most scenarios - you will probably need a ND32 if you fly anywhere really bright though (i.e. white sand beach), but otherwise you are off to a great start.

The exposure wheel on the Pro simply changes the manual settings, and doing so is going to give you uneven footage if you do that mid-shot. The Air has the ability to do that now too, after the latest update. This can be handy if you are able to pause you shooting for a couple seconds and adjust before resuming. You can also do this with a couple taps on your phone or whatever you're flying with - it's not a big deal either way. Changing exposure compensation on the Mavic Air changes the shutter speed.

Depending on what you're pointed at, exposure can certainly change mid-flight, but that is just something you need to deal with. If the sun dips behind a cloud your footage may become too dark, or if the landscape transitions from very dark to very bright/reflective, the footage might be blown out a bit. It's a balancing act for sure.

The "golden rule" is to use a shutter speed of 2X the FPS (i.e. 1/60sec shutter for 30FPS footage), but you won't see any negative effects if you need to bump that up a little bit. In fact if I am flying close to my subject, 1/60 gives too much blur and I like to use 1/100 or so. You can play around with things like this yourself and decide what is most appealing to you. Too fast of a shutter speed though and you will get a very choppy look to the footage, especially if there is anything with constant movement in it (like ocean waves). Too slow of a shutter speed and everything will just become blurry, especially if you are flying fast, low, and/or close to your subject. Don't get too caught up in the "golden rule", but make sure you're aware of how your changes may affect the footage.

If you're just flying around for fun and have the luxury to stop mid-air and adjust settings slightly as necessary, you have a lot less to worry about. If there is any dramatic change to the lighting conditions mid-flight, you will either need to change the ISO or shutter speed, and if neither is acceptable/possible, you'll probably need to land and swap ND filters.

A good exercise for you might be to fly a certain path on Auto mode, and then fly the same path at 1/60 shutter, ISO 100, and the proper ND filter and compare the two just to see how the footage looks. The 2X FPS rule is intended to give a more natural/cinematic look to the footage with natural motion blur and smooth transitions, but isn't always perfect for every scenario - for example if you have to use 1/80 I doubt you'll notice.
 
Full manual would just be manual mode in the drone's exposure settings, and selecting a manual white balance in the WB settings. It's simpler than it may sound, but can be intimidating at first.

With experience you will be able to look at the conditions and pretty much know what ND filter is required, but you can pick up the drone and point it at the scene to get a rough idea. Once you're in the air, you can tweak the shutter speed if necessary as you will have a little bit of leeway. Try not to raise ISO above 100, but if you need to in order to get the shot, obviously that is better than no shot. The ND set you have will be perfect for most scenarios - you will probably need a ND32 if you fly anywhere really bright though (i.e. white sand beach), but otherwise you are off to a great start.

The exposure wheel on the Pro simply changes the manual settings, and doing so is going to give you uneven footage if you do that mid-shot. The Air has the ability to do that now too, after the latest update. This can be handy if you are able to pause you shooting for a couple seconds and adjust before resuming. You can also do this with a couple taps on your phone or whatever you're flying with - it's not a big deal either way. Changing exposure compensation on the Mavic Air changes the shutter speed.

Depending on what you're pointed at, exposure can certainly change mid-flight, but that is just something you need to deal with. If the sun dips behind a cloud your footage may become too dark, or if the landscape transitions from very dark to very bright/reflective, the footage might be blown out a bit. It's a balancing act for sure.

The "golden rule" is to use a shutter speed of 2X the FPS (i.e. 1/60sec shutter for 30FPS footage), but you won't see any negative effects if you need to bump that up a little bit. In fact if I am flying close to my subject, 1/60 gives too much blur and I like to use 1/100 or so. You can play around with things like this yourself and decide what is most appealing to you. Too fast of a shutter speed though and you will get a very choppy look to the footage, especially if there is anything with constant movement in it (like ocean waves). Too slow of a shutter speed and everything will just become blurry, especially if you are flying fast, low, and/or close to your subject. Don't get too caught up in the "golden rule", but make sure you're aware of how your changes may affect the footage.

If you're just flying around for fun and have the luxury to stop mid-air and adjust settings slightly as necessary, you have a lot less to worry about. If there is any dramatic change to the lighting conditions mid-flight, you will either need to change the ISO or shutter speed, and if neither is acceptable/possible, you'll probably need to land and swap ND filters.

A good exercise for you might be to fly a certain path on Auto mode, and then fly the same path at 1/60 shutter, ISO 100, and the proper ND filter and compare the two just to see how the footage looks. The 2X FPS rule is intended to give a more natural/cinematic look to the footage with natural motion blur and smooth transitions, but isn't always perfect for every scenario - for example if you have to use 1/80 I doubt you'll notice.
Very well said. Thanks
 

DJI Drone Deals

New Threads

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
134,578
Messages
1,596,451
Members
163,079
Latest member
jhgfdhjrye
Want to Remove this Ad? Simply login or create a free account