I know I sound like a broken record, but it bears repeating... If you file a claim with SF for a loss, that claim WILL be entered into the LexisNexis risk rating database. This is the database that all insurers use to assess risk, and calculate underwriting risk when your policy renews. So even if SF is not your home/auto insurer, simply filing a claim with them for a loss WILL show up as a chargeable claim (increased risk rating) when home/auto policies renew.
The SF agent I spoke with said that if you are long-term (loyal) SF customer, and you renew your existing policies, such a claim would NOT affect your rates. BUT, if you try to purchase new auto/home insurance, your rates WILL be affected, since the new company will have no first-hand knowledge of your risk profile.
Therefore, if you are happy with your current auto and home insurers, and you have a long established history with them and have no intention to shop around at renewal, then the SF PAP route is a safe and effective way to insure your MP.
However, if you are like many who use brokers and shop/compare rates for home/auto at regular intervals, filing a claim with SF for your MP will all but guarantee you will no longer be eligible for the best rates.
Here are her comments:
A personal articles policy (PAP) policy is considered a “fire” policy. Under the fire category is home, PAP, and inland marine policies. If there is a claim on any of these policies, it is recorded in Lexus Nexus and does affect your future rating if you intend to get any of those policies started as new business.
With State Farm (I can’t speak for other companies) if you do a PAP claim during a time where you have an existing home policy, it will not affect your rate. As I mentioned before, however, if you start a new home policy, it does have the potential to affect that...
Any claim on any property policy could be considered during underwriting for rating purposes by any carrier, so it’s no different than having an auto claim and then shopping your auto policy after.
Essentially, filing a claim on your MP has the same negative potential on your risk rating as an auto accident. Consider carefully whether that is a sensible option based on your insurance practices. Since I shop every year for best rates, a SF policy for the MP makes little sense.