DJI Mavic, Air and Mini Drones
Friendly, Helpful & Knowledgeable Community
Join Us Now

Wind Test?

@Meta4 How do you know those figures are the MAX air speeds?
How do I know?
I explained that clearly in the previous post.
Read it again.
They are certainly the max ground speeds as the drone won't exceed these in still air or with a tailwind.
DJI puts the brakes on (by reducing tilt), preventing the drone getting any significant groundspeed boost from a tailwind.
That seems to be confusing you, but it makes no difference to the max airspeed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Droniac
The max airspeed is limited by the max tilt angle.
And it's the same for both drones.
Max Tilt Angle 30° (S Mode)
Post #19 is quite clear, but reading it again won't help make it correct, especially the part quoted above.

As previously stated I don't think it really could go much faster than 13m/s in S mode. This is is NOT due to limited max tilt as the drone doesn't even use the full 30deg tilt to achieve 13m/s. Further evidence that tilt isn't limiting the speed is given by increasing the max tilt to higher than 30 (I've experimented with 40deg) - no increase in top speed is observed.

You've acknowledged that DJI has included a firmware speed limiter to stop you exceeding the mode's max groundspeed by using a tailwind. If you fly in still air and give full fwd stick the drone will reach 13m/s in S mode. This is the speed at which the speed limiter would prevent any further increase in speed, whether the aircraft was capable of going any faster or not (I don't believe the Mini 1 can, but not for the reason you've presented)

I believe maximum air speed of the Mini1 is limited due to max thrust. A certain amount of thrust is required to stay airborne, and any available thrust beyond that can be used to push the aircraft forward. As the drone tilts further to give a larger horizontal component to its thrust vector the body of the aircraft starts to provide downthrust - essentially its relatively flat upper and lower surfaces act like a crude airfoil. The higher the forward speed the greater this thrust becomes, so the more of the total thrust is required just to maintain altitude, and the less spare is available to push the aircraft forward. This would mean that the aircraft couldn't use its full tilt to achieve its max airspeed, and this agrees well with my observation that at 13m/s in still air the Mini 1 doesn't use 30deg of tilt.

Now, if you rebuilt the Mini1 with more powerful motors and a slightly better battery to feed these motors, it would have a little bit more thrust, and could potentially achieve higher airspeeds. But If the 13m/s speed limiter was still in place then you'd never exceed a ground speed of 13m/s but could potentially exceed an airspeed of 13m/s. This would manifest itself as better wind resistance and tallies with the observations presented in post #17.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Crash and Burn
When I fly my DJI drones against a headwind, their indicated speed = max airspeed - speed of the wind.
They have no extra reserve they can draw on to reach a higher airspeed.
Their max speed in still air is their max airspeed.
 
I found this video showing the Mini 2 struggling with a strong wind ... really impressed!

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
I might do some testing in our tunnel sometime soon. Will get students to design some testing protocols


C88C69B3-15D4-4E72-BD65-ECA5BA16675A.jpeg
 
DJI MINI 2 vs EVO 2 PRO | WIND & CRASH TEST INTO WIND TUNNEL - WIND TUNNEL Perugia
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Crash and Burn

DJI Drone Deals

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
134,578
Messages
1,596,448
Members
163,078
Latest member
dewitt00
Want to Remove this Ad? Simply login or create a free account